717-925-0041
Welcome to Shoofly Pie Country!
Our best-seller is Lancaster County's Amish style, premium Shoofly Pies. Our premier pies are oh-so-tasty (the best around!), a pleasure to taste and eat!

Our Specials page is here. All orders can take advantage of $5 flat-rate Ground shipping (we use USPS Priority Mail and FedEx Home Delivery).
Featured Products
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Black Raspberry Jam, Seedless, Half Pint, Pack of 2
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Black Raspberry Jam, Seedless, Half Pint, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $12.95
On sale: $12.15 On Sale
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade "7 Day" Sweet Pickles, Pint, Pack of 2
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade "7 Day" Sweet Pickles, Pint, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $18.95
On sale: $17.55 On Sale
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Apricot Jam, Half Pint, Pack of 2
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Apricot Jam, Half Pint, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $10.95
On sale: $10.35 On Sale
Allgyer's Home Canning Homemade Chow-Chow, Pint, Pack of 2
Allgyer's Home Canning Homemade Chow-Chow, Pint, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $16.95
On sale: $16.15 On Sale
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Pumpkin Butter, Pack of 2
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Pumpkin Butter, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $9.50
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Elderberry Jelly, Half Pint, Pack of 2
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Elderberry Jelly, Half Pint, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $10.95
Beanie's Homestyle Dipping Mustard, Pack of 2
Beanie's Homestyle Dipping Mustard, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $16.95
Dutch Country Soft Pretzel Mix, Pack of 2
Dutch Country Soft Pretzel Mix, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $21.95
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Strawberry Jam, Half Pint, Pack of 2
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Strawberry Jam, Half Pint, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $10.95
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Pear Butter, Pack of 2
Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Pear Butter, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $9.95
Jake 'n Amos Corn Relish, Pint, Pack of 2
Jake 'n Amos Corn Relish, Pint, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $9.95
Whole Wheat Noodles, Homemade by Little Barn Noodles, 1 Lb., Pack of 2
Whole Wheat Noodles, Homemade by Little Barn Noodles, 1 Lb., Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $16.95
Lancaster Canning Seedless Red Raspberry Jam, 12 Oz., Pack of 2
Lancaster Canning Seedless Red Raspberry Jam, 12 Oz., Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $12.95
Lancaster Canning Homemade Grape Jelly, 12 Oz., Pack of 2
Lancaster Canning Homemade Grape Jelly, 12 Oz., Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $12.95
Jake 'n Amos Hot Sweet Pepper Relish, Pint
Jake 'n Amos Hot Sweet Pepper Relish, Pint
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $6.50
Jake 'n Amos Old Fashioned Sauerkraut, Pint, Pack of 2
Jake 'n Amos Old Fashioned Sauerkraut, Pint, Pack of 2
Average Rating 0 Review(s)
Your Price: $11.50